[Wien] spin-orbit and forces
Stefaan Cottenier
Stefaan.Cottenier at fys.kuleuven.ac.be
Fri Oct 15 14:50:58 CEST 2004
Dear Wien-community,
In a calculation of a heavy impurity (Pb) in a heavy host lattice (hcp-Re),
I noticed the following behaviour which I don't understand:
First I relax the position of several neighbour shells around the impurity,
without spin-orbit coupling (it doesn't make sense to do this with
spin-orbit, as the forces by wien2k are incorrect for spin-orbit anyway).
Then I rerun the relaxed case with spin-orbit (adding spin-orbit has a
significant effect on e.g. the EFG of all the atoms). In this spin-orbit
calculation, the forces without the FOR switch are somewhat different from
the ones without spin-orbit, but with the FOR switch they are crazy :
grepline :FGL013 '*.scf' 3
no-SO.scf::FGL013: 13.ATOM 221.045 190.184
0.081
no-SO.scf::FGL013: 13.ATOM 221.067 190.208
0.195
no-SO.scf::FGL013: 13.ATOM 1.120
0.036 -0.079
with-SO.scf::FGL013: 13.ATOM 214.047 185.388
0.151
with-SO.scf::FGL013: 13.ATOM 214.040 185.393
0.095
with-SO.scf::FGL013:
OM -440.734 -3270.016 -582.134
(every time in the last iteration FOR is switched on)
I know one that the forces with spin-orbit are meaningless numbers in
wien2k, but I cannot remember to have met such high values before, and this
worries me a bit (indication of an error somewhere?). Can somebody confirm
that forces-with-SO can really go wild, or can somebody point me to the
likely error if this would not happen to be the case?
Basis set, k-mesh and Emax are well-converged, in1new is used.
Thanks,
Stefaan
More information about the Wien
mailing list